ireactions wrote:I don't know if you're a STAR TREK fan, but STAR TREK CONTINUES isn't like those unfortunate amateur STAR TREK films that litter the internet. STAR TREK CONTINUES looks, sounds and feels like an actual 60s episode of STAR TREK at its peak quality. The cinematography, performances, music and writing are so purposeful and filled with intent and meaning, unlike amateur fanfilms where the actors have no idea why they're saying what they're saying and the directors have no idea what information they're delivering and the cinematographers have no idea what the shot means to the story that they are telling. STAR TREK CONTINUES is excellent. And I consider it canon to me, but it still isn't canon. The same way I consider all SLIDERS fan fiction canon up to and including every random story idea on this message board -- while noting that it's a minority opinion.
Maybe someday, AI can achieve something as genuine to STAR TREK as STAR TREK CONTINUES for other franchises... but even then, it still wouldn't be canon. I consider the X-FILES comics to be more canon than the TV show, but again -- it's a minority opinion.
I did a bit of googling yesterday briefly and noticed how high the imdb rating was and the stills I saw of the show is very close to the 60s version.
It seems like a great project. And not a bad comparison for the purposes of this dicussion, though not a 1-to-1 either. There's a kirk like character... but nobody would ever think that's specfically Kirk. Same for other cast. Although I can totally how some fans may feel like it's well done enough to take as cannon. Even if it's not official cannon, the fact that it is cannon to you actually goes back to the spirit of what I was asking. If it's cannon to you, and you can enjoy it as such, then that's a yay. It doesnt have to be cannon to all fans but if some can enjoy it as such, well then, I think that is an interesting opportunity for what AI can give those fans.
I think for me, when I think of the franchises I love... Back to the Future, Blade Runner, Sliders.... well, I would never regard any AI stuff as bttf cannon. I could totally embrace a metaverse/vr world version of Blade Runner where you can interact with the characters as in-universe, real stuff. VR implementation of this tech will inevitably come in decades. That is the future of entertainment, to be able to step into the world. That said, AI generated fan stories in 2d format for Blade Runner I wouldnt regard as cannon unless expectionally well done and feeling rather true. The bar would be super high.
Now Sliders, since it's dead, and it's not back to the future, and it feels like property that has a never ending amount of stories and travels - anthological -- stuff that doesn't contradict or get in the way of any official cannon, well, I could accept potentially stories about worlds and the adventures our gang has taken them as cannon, under the right circumstances. I wouldnt ever accept content relating to origin stories as cannon because that feels like something which should come from the creator. If we are talking earth prime cannon. Now if there was audio dramas or realistic video content of a story of the week on a world, and it was well done, and it captured the original tone and voice of the creator? I think I could probably embrace it as in-universe. If the production quality felt polished and not like a fan effort, and if the tech allows for that.
The bigger opportunity may be though to take scripts that were never done, story ideas, from the creator and making it come alive. That would feel cannon.
Many months ago, and even last year, I think i've referenced the possibilities for the future with Sliders with regard to technology, and what it may allow. But I never thought it was just around the corner. Now I am seeing stories every day that make it clear, lord this stuff is close, or is certain to be a reality. Another industry that this is relevant is the music industry. You have Tupac rapping songs originally song by Eminem or Nas. For fans in that space, they are torn because on one hand, some of the stuff sounds really good. Some of them love it, and an opportunity to enjoy the artist in a different way. And for some, it feels wrong. Nobody will likely feel the same about this stuff. And I am sure the same person can feel both ways.
It will be an interesting time, and I think eventually we will see the tools to at least start being more "makers" in the Sliders universe with experiences that are more visceral than the written word. In my opinion, that is exciting because when you put all your hope into a studio to make new material, and the corporate powers aren't gonna care that much about a niche-type property, it empowers us in a way and makes us less dependant on them.