So I think I officially hate the Star Wars sequels.
Not because of Rian Johnson or Mary Sues or black stormtroopers or Rose or Snoke or Reylo or Palpatine returning somehow or any of the main reasons people don't like the sequels. I just think they're depressing to think about, especially as they flesh out the universe with superior content.
In the Mandalorian, things are still mostly grim. It never seems like people are thriving. But we've seen glimpses of hope for a better tomorrow. The New Republic is doing its best to undo what the Empire did. They're trying to dismantle and rehabilitate and chart a new future. And in shows like Andor and the Clone Wars, we learn more about Mon Mothma. And since Mon Mothma is the chancellor in the New Republic, when we meet her and learn about her, we start to cheer for her.
We are seeing a hopeful Luke starting to train new Jedi and the Force seems to be healing the world. Force-sensitive children are allowed to live and thrive for the first time in 30 years.
But....who cares about any of that when we know it's all going to come crashing down? The prequels are supposed to have an ominous feel to them because we know the Republic is going to fall and the Empire will rise. But it's okay because we know how it ends.
And, yeah, the sequels have a happy ending....sort of. And maybe it's enough that Luke and Leia get to enjoy that happy ending through the Force. But it just feels like the Original Trilogy is a waste of time. Everything that happens in the Original Trilogy doesn't matter. They don't defeat the Empire (really). They don't even defeat Palpatine. They make things slightly better on a few planets and redeem Anakin. That's really it.
And that just sucks. The prequel trilogy is about the hubris of the Jedi and how democracy is delicate. The Jedi could've stopped Palpatine easily if they hadn't gotten cocky. The Republic should've been strong enough to resist the Empire. But hubris is real and democracy is delicate.
What's the lesson from the original trilogy now? It's still that even the worst man can be redeemed. But the band of heroes fails in the end. They all end up with fairly pointless deaths. Leia essentially exhausts herself because she has to do everything all over.
And what sucks is that the lessons from the sequels are able to discredit the happy endings made by the sequels. Sure, maybe Rey has learned from the failures of the Jedi, but who's to say her new path will go any better than Luke's. Luke wasn't tainted by thousands of years of Jedi laziness. Even with books and teaching, he was essentially charting his own path like Rey is going to. I wouldn't think there'd be anything to stop one of Rey's new students from pulling a Kylo Ren and pulling the whole thing down.
And maybe there will be a New New Republic, but who's going to lead it? And why would we think they'd be any more successful than Mon Mothma was?
I always wanted to see the sequels. Yes, I wanted to see a badass Luke Skywalker at the height of his power, but it's just fun to see what things look like once the story is over. And I think there's stories to tell when a fledgling government is starting over. And, trust me, I think de-politicizing (and by that I mean less focus on galactic politics, not messaging) Star Wars in the sequels was a good idea. But I don't think anyone making The Force Awakens thought about the message they were sending. They just wanted to remake A New Hope and needed a new Empire.
The original trilogy was about the fall of Rome. The original trilogy was about revolution. Maybe the sequel trilogy should've been about civil war. Maybe people in the galaxy liked certain aspects of the reign of the empire and the security it brought them. Maybe they fight back against a young republic trying to learn how to walk. Maybe disarming ends up weakening them and forces inside the republic start talking about re-arming and becoming more militaristic. Maybe there begins to be talk of sending Luke's new Jedi to fight this war.
The prequels start to repeat themselves.
And maybe people like Mothma and Luke and Leia and Han show that they've learned from the mistakes of the past and start making the right decisions. Maybe Luke learns that the Jedi can't be soldiers or special forces or even peacekeepers - maybe they need to be something else. Maybe Mothma and Leia can find a balance between being peaceful and being strong.
And you wouldn't even need to change much about the characters. Rey is Luke's promising young student who feels conflicted because she misses her old life and family. Poe is a hotshot pilot who wants to protect the New Republic at any cost. Finn is a defector of the people that don't like the chaos that the end of the Empire brought to certain places in the galaxy.
And you can still have Starkiller Base and underdog space fights and hopeless situations and lightsaber fights. But you don't have to undermine everything that the previous movies taught us.
It makes me sad for an stories that are coming on Star Wars TV. And it makes me feel hopeless about Episodes 10-12 making the same mistakes.