Grizzlor wrote:WW84 was vapid, and like everything else these days, 45 minutes too long.
It's interesting for you to say that because I had the opposite thought. I think somehow this movie needed to be longer - which I know is crazy. But I feel like if you chopped out 45 minutes, it would suffer from the BvS syndrome of the plot no longer making sense. I think there's a version of this film that makes sense and be 45 minutes shorter, but I think you'd need to completely remove the Cheetah subplot. Then the movie loses a couple action sequences and the climax is Wonder Woman making an empassioned speech. I think it's more likely that they'd cut the Steve Trevor stuff, which is really where the movie works best.
I think the BvS Ultimate Edition is a great comparison because I think the movie is really compelling but falls apart when under scrutiny. It also has an insane runtime but also doesn't spend the time wisely or efficiently. BvS had several scenes with Batman and Alfred, but almost none of it helps explain why Batman is acting the way he's acting or whether or not things were ever different. There's a ton about Superman but almost nothing in it humanizes him. A ton with Lex but very little to explain his motivations.
So you have a bloated movie that tells a big story but struggles to answer any questions. And that's what happens with WW84. I have a ton of questions about how the Dreamstone works, and despite a 150 minute runtime, they don't seem terribly interested in explaining it. Did Lord have a supernatural understanding of what people cherish the most, or was he randomly picking things he wanted? With the first Arab oil baron, he asks for the oil without knowing the the oil wasn't his. Then he takes the security team. So it seems like he can just take what he wants but he doesn't have any supernatural knowledge. But then at the end, how does he know what to take?
Are Diana's powers really what Diana treasures the most? That seems odd. I know she likes being a hero, but maybe she should've lost her concern for civilians? Her heroism?
And what did Lord lose? I kept thinking that he'd lose his son, but that never happened. I'm sure they didn't want to kill a kid, but it seems weird that Lord didn't seem to have any downside to his wish. Did he also lose his humanity? He definitely went power hungry, but was he always like that?
And the rules seemed different. Some people lost everything immediately. Barbara and Diana seemed to lose their treasured thing gradually. But Max's partner was taken to jail almost immediately.
What was the point of Steve inhabiting some stranger? Even the movie seemed to forget that plot point at times.
All in all, I don't think cutting things would work unless you cut things and then added other things. The dreamstone part was the part that was the most confusing, but you can't cut that part out or the movie makes even less sense. Again, you could cut Barbara, but you lose some fun scenes and lose some action beats.
TemporalFlux wrote:First that comes to mind is Lobo. It would fit perfectly with his visions of violence, blood, gore and surrealism.
I actually had that thought. I think that would be really interesting.