I watched it again. I still just don't see the appeal of this movie. It's just nostalgia...there's nothing more to it.
The problem is that I leave with so many questions that I wonder how it's possible that I've just watched a 150-minute movie.
Things we know about Rey: she's brave, she's strong with the Force, she has a mysterious past.
Things we know about Finn: he's brave, he's noble, and he has a mysterious past.
Things we know about Poe: he's brave, he's a good pilot, and we know nothing about his past.
Things we know about Maz: she's been around 1000 years with a mysterious past.
And these are the main characters!
I know Luke and Han aren't great characters in A New Hope, but we knew some things about Luke. His father died at the hands of Darth Vader. He was a great warrior, a great friend, and a great pilot. Luke lives with his aunt and uncle. He wants to leave the planet because he feels a pull to the bigger conflicts.
All we know about Rey is that she feels a pull to the bigger conflicts and wants to fight....but instead of wanting to leave, she wants to stay. But we don't know anything about her parents and almost nothing of her past.
The movie is so secretive, not letting us know anything to try and set up a number of "I am your father" moments, but that means that nostalgia has to carry the entire film. And for a lot of people, that was enough. For me, I'm wondering what the Hell happened.
I watch the scene where the Starkiller base fires and destroys that system, and it raises a hundred questions that the movie refuses to give any insight into. How did the First Order rise from the rubble of the Empire to, once again, be the most powerful force of the galaxy? Who is the New Republic, and why is its capital in some system we've never heard of (instead of Coruscant? Why are the Resistance and the New Republic separate? Shouldn't the Resistance just be the fleet of the New Republic? Why does Princess Leia work for the Resistance and not the New Republic?
And I get that this is a movie that can afford to raise questions and not answer them because movies 8 and 9 would be coming no matter what. This is season one of a show that's guaranteed to be renewed. And, yeah, there's enough fun stuff in the movie that you don't ask the questions until later.
But, really, this movie couldn't afford to give us anything? Anything at all?