ireactions wrote:I wonder if EPISODE IX will open with Leia's funeral, Leia having died peacefully in her sleep.
Possibly, but what a bummer that would be. Not only in the story....but in real life because we know she's really dead. As we saw when Fisher died, Leia means something to people. And when Fisher was stolen from us, it might mean Leia was stolen from us too.
Movies are generally pretty kind. Every human being dies, but our heroes don't usually have to. Christopher Nolan's Batman gets to keep living forever. Maybe he and Selina get old and have kids and he dies surrounded by grandkids and people that love him. We can write our own ending, and it can be as happy as we want. Maybe he finds a Lazarus Pit and lives forever. We don't have to worry about it.
And when our favorite people die, it usually means something. Han Solo dying was sad, but it was important. He was trying to save his son. He was trying to redeem himself. He was trying....something. He knew it was dangerous, and he probably knew, deep down, that it was stupid. But he didn't care...it was what his heart was telling him to do.
If we open with a funeral, it won't feel like a movie. It'll feel cheap, and it'll feel.....real. We don't watch movies for real. At least, we don't watch Star Wars movies for real. We know that sometimes people die before their time, but we don't want our heroes to. Their deaths either don't happen or happen for a reason.
If she dies in her sleep off screen....it's going to be really weird. I still suspect that Leia was supposed to play a big part in turning Kylo Ren around. When facing his father, he lashed out. When facing his mother, he'd turn around.
And the problem is that, as I've criticized before, Episode 7 wasn't a movie but a pilot for a 3-part TV show. Every move was a setup for a later move. I'm guessing Episode 8 is also more about setting up Episode 9 than being a singular movie. So, as I've been saying, I'm guessing that the choice was between massive rewrites or rolling with a CGI Leia.
Even if Star Killer Base II blows up Leia's ship during the opening of Episode 9, it's going to feel cheap. They could set it up like the opening of Star Trek (09), where Leia saves everyone else on board, and it's still going to feel cheap.
Life is cheap. I don't think (these) movies should be. I'd love for Leia to live even though Carrie Fisher didn't. But, as you said, it's a really neat creative challenge.