Okay having slept on it, there are my thoughts:
The Good
- I wanted Trump to look old and crazy, and oh boy. I thought she might lean into him being old, but I guess she didn't think that it would work with Biden being older. I think it was the only attack that she didn't attempt, but Trump certainly faded as the evening went on. His final statement was pathetic.
- "THEY'RE EATING THE DOGS" will be the sound byte of the debate. I imagine we will see the Harris campaign use that to show how unhinged Trump is.
- Trump set up Kamala to be so dumb and incompetent that she didn't really need to do much to surpass those expectations. She had some flaws (which I'll get to), but she was extremely prepared, she was (mostly) composed, and I think she came across as ready for the job. I don't want to say "presidential" because I think that word has been mangled a bit, but she did well.
- I was impressed that ABC did any fact checking on the fly, and they hit him on the two biggest points. Like Grizzlor said, he actually argued with them on the dogs thing which was insane for him. They also confirmed that in no state is it legal to "execute" a baby which also made him look radical (and dumb).
- Polymarket (which might be slanted to the right, I don't know a ton about it) had her overwhelmingly as the winner and it caused the race to move. CNN had her winning big (24 points I think). The pundits made it all about Trump and how crazy he looked.
- I think this will make Trump go even crazier, and I assume it continues to hurt him.
The Bad
- Not a ton, but Kamala did dodge questions. She ignored the first question about whether people are better off than they were four years ago. She ignored the question about Afghanistan. She ignored most of the question about her flip-flopping. This isn't necessarily a problem because I think she mostly got away with it. I think it will be important for her to continue to address it.
- She could've been more specific on her plans and separating herself from Biden. She wants to paint herself as a new direction, but she didn't really respond to how she'd be different than Biden.
- I think she had the opportunity to either own certain things or deflect some of the "blame" on Biden for certain things. "I will do X different than Biden did" or "Here's how I would have handled X." To be clear, I would not want her to throw Biden under the bus, but it would've been good for her to distance herself from Biden on a thing or two.
- I also think she needed to hammer home that Trump was responsible for a lot of the economic issues. I think she was strong on charting a new course for the economy (whether she can do it or not), but I thought she was weak on explaining the truth behind the economy.
- It was good for her to essentially let Trump look argumentative and let him speak, but I think she could've called for another minute of time a few times to call out something Trump said on rebuttal.
The Unknowns
- Does it matter? Did enough undecideds watch? Will enough undecideds pay attention? Did enough soft Republicans get turned off by the version of Trump they saw? And did any of those people live in the seven battleground states?
- Can Harris capitalize? She should regain some of the momentum she lost. I'm sure she made a ton of money last night, and I can't imagine the Trump campaign will be able to fundraise much from that. Pennsylvania is obviously the golden goose, but there's a path for her to win the other states and win the election. She needs either North Carolina or Georgia, and she'd need to sweep the others. She's massively outspending Trump everywhere but Pennsylvania so she needs to match/beat him there and hope to make inroads everywhere else.
- Will the mainstream media cover the debate "normally" or cover some of his unhinged moments? I watched almost no post-debate coverage so I'm not sure whether "THEY'RE EATING THE DOGS" was shown on the news last night / this morning or if they focused on the more coherent sound bytes.
The Swifties
I think it's better to have Taylor Swift's endorsement, but I don't know if it moves the needle at all. I assume anyone who was going to vote for Harris already did, and any Trump supporters that listen to Taylor probably won't flip. I think there's a slight chance that she can bring in some young voters, but I assume a lot of that work was already done.