S
P
O
I
L
E
R
S
So I agree we shouldn't hold the Legacy title against it. Maybe there was more legacy stuff and he ended up streamlining it. It was a good decision to drop the subtitle.
It's funny...I do this a lot where I rewrite movies in my head. Or in this case, I wrote Superman: Legacy in my head. To me, I was thinking it might be interesting if the movie took place after the Justice Society (or just another team of superheroes) had aged out. And when something (I assumed Brainaic) shows up, this second generation of heroes was going to have to step in and save the day...along with this brand new guy who doesn't know where he fits. There would be a second Green Lantern (although I know he's the third one), a second Hawkgirl, a second Mr. Terrific - these heroes who have a clear legacy that they're following in. And Clark, who's trying to blaze his own trail. And how each of those has positives and negatives. Clark could tell Guy how scary it is to be out on his own and be this alien and not sure if people will trust him. And Guy could say that he's always being compared to Hal and how he wished he could be his own guy.
That's what I thought the movie would be. It would be a fresh start but it would feel lived in.
The post-credits scene was confusing to me. Were they repairing the city, or was that just how the city reformed? There's the scene at the end after the portal is closed where the building comes back together on its own. That's what I assumed the building at the end was done, but obviously the scene doesn't make any sense if that's the case because why would Terrific feel any ownership of how that building came back together?
I enjoyed the movie, but... it's very lightweight. Superman's parents being supervillains didn't really have the heavy, dark weight it could have because the film is so good-natured and gentle that it never really feels like a big deal. Superman's efforts to keep everything bloodless is great, but it also leads to a certain absence of threat and danger because it's hard to believe anyone can really get hurt... although the one casualty is indeed very upsetting.
It's funny. Most of the criticism I've seen is that the movie is too messy, and I do think that some of the movie could've been streamlined a bit. The movie, to me at least, was trying to talk about what it means to be human. Because I think Clark has every right to think of himself as a human. And as long as the movie ended with Clark telling Lex that, I think the movie would've been good.